Anonymous said: im the one who said shin hyesungs voice isnt all that heavenly. geez its just an opinion. why is everyone so angry, this fandom's sick
I reread your initial ask to Kanon-SHCJ, and I realized I let the situation and others’ take on it influence me. Because of that, I failed to see the genuine curiosity within your question and aimed solely to prove a point. Please accept my apologies for that.
As with all anonymously submitted things like such, and especially across the internet, it is easy to misread (and by extension, misinterpret) one’s intentions. The majority of us probably took your honesty as an attack on something we cherish—an insult, if you will.
Yes, it is your opinion, and yes, I do respect it! We all have our own opinions, do we not? It’s terrible to attack someone just because their views differ.
In your defense, I will whole-heartedly agree that we overreacted as a group. In the defense of my “sick” fandom, the choice of words in that ask can be considered provocative in some way, to an extent.
To conclude my lengthly explanation, I would just like to say I personally did not mean to offend you in any way nor berate you for your own opinions, and I apologize if I did. As for the Shinhwa Changjo fandom, I hope you understand and sympathize with the continuous backlash and negative attention our idols seem to attract, and thus we have developed the tendency to jump into a protective, indignitive stance as soon as we’re provoked.
In light of all this, I do hope you have given the videos we’ve linked a chance. Perhaps it is no longer to try and convince you that Hyesung indeed has a ‘heavenly voice’, but merely to experience.
Have a nice day, and take care!
No I’m sorry. I’m not going to let this person put the blame all on SHCJ saying we over-reacted and this fandom is sick. Stand up anon and take some of the blame yourself. It’s not that you said you didn’t like his voice or that you liked another’s better. Frankly I don’t give a crap if you don’t like his voice. That’s your opinion. There are many in the fandom that likes Dongwan’s voice better. It’s fine.
No. It was this statement right here I bet half of his stans only like him for his face or whatever. you should know since ur his fan ryt?? that set off many of us (and yes even though I didn’t say anything about it at the time, it angered me a bit). Do you realize that you are basically negating everyone else’s opinion but your own because you don’t like his voice. So since you don’t like it then anyone who does like it is automatically wrong so the only possible reason we could like him is because he has a pretty face? Then when people come back and give you strongly worded examples of why we like his voice you want to act the victim and then call us sick? No I’m not going to let you do that.
Stand up and take part of the blame for inciting this by belittling everyone else’s opinion.
Once again, I don’t care if you don’t like his voice or don’t think it’s heavenly. It’s your opinion. You just happened to state it in a way that was sure to incite conflict.
always. all the time. offend the whole fandom with “I bet half of his stans only like him for his face or whatever. you should know since ur his fan ryt??”,
then stated “just my opinion” //rollseyes//
Ones shall learn how to voice ‘opinion’ without negating others’, like what sara said above..
You started provoking us. We reacted. You get offended yourselves, blame on us, while you actually asked for it with “I bet half of his stans only like him for his face or whatever. you should know since ur his fan ryt??”.